Richmond Builds the Machines That Move 4th grade · age 9
In its advertisements, the Starr Piano Company told families across America why they should buy a piano made in Richmond, Indiana. What did the makers of Starr pianos want people to believe about their pianos and their company?
The source
The Starr Piano Company, Toledo, Ohio
About this document
As you read, the Starr Piano Company started making pianos in Richmond, Indiana, in 1872. The railroads that came through Richmond in the 1850s let factory owners ship their goods to customers all across the country. By the early 1900s, the Starr Piano Company had grown into a huge business with more than 600 workers and buildings that covered about ten football fields of floor space.
This advertisement was posted on March 4, 1907, at the Starr Piano Company's store in Toledo, Ohio. It announced that two full train cars of pianos were arriving that Monday morning. The ad called the company "The Largest and Most Complete Piano House in the Middle West" and "World Renowned," and it listed several different piano brands (Starr, Chase, Richmond, Remington, and Player-Pianos).

The Starr Piano Company. “The Starr Piano Company, Toledo, Ohio.” Wikimedia Commons, 1907-03-04, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File%3AThe%20Starr%20Piano%20Company%2C%20Toledo%2C%20Ohio%20-%20DPLA%20-%20e09722a1c9f29a4ac0d68054fc275f6c%20%28page%201%29.jpg.
Your turn
Setting the scene
What has happened in our unit story by the time this document was created?
What does it say?
What is the main image in the center of this advertisement? Describe what you see in the photograph, including the building and anything on the street in front of it.
Look at the words printed around the photograph. What words and phrases can you find at the very top of the advertisement, along the left side, and at the very bottom?
Now look at the words printed to the right of the photograph. What does this part of the advertisement tell you is happening, and what piano names does it list?
What does it mean?
The advertisement includes a photograph of a big, fancy building with multiple floors. Why do you think the makers of this ad chose to show this large building instead of just listing the pianos they sell? What do they want families to think when they see it?
The ad says the company is "Unloading two car loads" of pianos. From what you've read, why would the makers of this ad want people to know that pianos are arriving by train car? What does that tell customers about the company?
The ad lists five different kinds of pianos — Starr, Richmond, Chase, Remington, and Player-Pianos. Why do you think the ad makers wanted families to see so many different names and types? What are they trying to get people to believe about the Starr Piano Company?
Look at the words at the top: "THE LARGEST AND MOST COMPLETE PIANO HOUSE IN THE MIDDLE WEST" and the words at the bottom: "TOLEDO'S LEADING PIANO HOUSE." On the left side it also says "World Renowned." Why do you think the ad makers used words like "largest," "leading," and "World Renowned"? What feeling were they trying to give families reading this ad?
Write your answer
Use the Starr Piano Company advertisement from 1907 to complete our Primary Source Lab: In its advertisements, the Starr Piano Company told families across America why they should buy a piano made in Richmond, Indiana. What did the makers of Starr pianos want people to believe about their pianos and their company?
From Richmond Builds the Machines That Move, a 4th grade history lesson on Pallas.