Richmond Builds the Machines That Move 4th grade · age 9

Richmond's early settlers put their own money into small local shops and factories, and later the town helped pay for the canal project that a flood destroyed in 1847. Should the people of Richmond have kept spending their shared money to help local manufacturers get connected to markets, even after the canal failed and the money was lost?

Under what conditions do we owe our money or help to other people in our community?

Our Judgment Lab asks: What do we think about that? When we complete our Judgment Lab, our ultimate goal is to articulate our own principles and values in a thoughtful and respectful way.

Richmond, Indiana, started out as a small town far from any river or port. There was no easy way to send goods to faraway customers. The early settlers worked hard to fix this problem. They put their own money into small workshops and factories, and their leaders came up with a plan to build a canal that would connect Richmond to the Ohio River. Investors spent about $45,000 on the canal, but a terrible flood in 1847 destroyed the whole project. All that money was lost, and Richmond's leaders gave up on the canal.

Even after that big loss, the people of Richmond did not quit. During the 1840s, they opened three new toll roads heading in different directions to connect their town to nearby places. Then, in the 1850s, railroads came through Richmond, enabling factory owners to ship goods by train to customers all across the country. The town's population jumped by more than 5,000 people as workers moved in to fill new jobs. This allowed Richmond to grow into one of the top manufacturing cities of its size in the western part of the country by the early 1900s.

When the general question asks about owing our money or help to other people in our community, it means feeling like we should chip in — with cash, time, or effort — to help the people who live and work near us. A community is a group of people who share a place, like a town or a neighborhood, and who depend on each other to make that place work well.

Should the people of Richmond have kept putting their shared money toward helping local businesses reach new customers, even after the canal flooded and all that money washed away?

Follow the steps below to complete this Judgment Lab. By the end of the lab, you will have decided whether you think the people of Richmond should have kept spending their shared money to help local manufacturers get connected to markets, even after the canal failed and the money was lost. You will also articulate and test your principles about under what conditions we owe our money or help to other people in our community.

Step one

Generating claims

Richmond's early settlers put their own money into small local shops and factories, and later the town helped pay for the canal project that a flood destroyed in 1847. Should the people of Richmond have kept spending their shared money to help local manufacturers get connected to markets, even after the canal failed and the money was lost?

Yes

No

Step two

Articulating principles and values

Under what conditions do we owe our money or help to other people in our community?

Always, never, or sometimes?

Principles

I think that we owe our money or help to other people in our community when...

Values and beliefs

I think that because I believe that...

Step three

Testing principles on a new case

The Erie Canal in New York

In the early 1800s, New York State had a problem a lot like Richmond's. Farmers and workers who lived far inland, near Buffalo and Lake Erie, had no cheap way to send their goods to the big city of New York. Wagons crawling over dirt roads cost a fortune. In 1817, Governor DeWitt Clinton talked the state lawmakers into a huge plan: dig a canal 363 miles across the whole state, from Albany to Buffalo, so boats could float goods all the way to the ocean.

New York paid for it with shared public money. The state borrowed about seven million dollars and also collected taxes on things like salt and steamboat tickets. Lots of people thought it was a foolish waste. Every year the costs climbed higher, and the lawmakers had to vote again to keep paying.

The canal eventually opened in October 1825. It ended up working better than almost anyone expected. Shipping a ton of goods from Buffalo to New York City had cost around one hundred dollars by wagon; by canal boat it dropped to under ten. Tolls paid the whole loan back within about ten years. Towns like Rochester and Syracuse grew into cities along the water, and New York City became the busiest port in the country.

Apply your principle to the new case

According to your general principle, should the people of New York have kept spending their shared public money on the Erie Canal, even while costs kept climbing? Why or why not?

From Richmond Builds the Machines That Move, a 4th grade history lesson on Pallas.

Free with your school email

Every file — the reading and notes PDFs, work pages, primary-source labs, and the teacher edition (slides, lesson plan, exemplars) — is free. Tell us your school or organization email and we’ll send the file straight to your inbox.

Personal addresses (gmail, yahoo…) won’t work — we build for classrooms. We will email you about new units from Pallas. No spam; unsubscribe any time.