Monroe Seiberling and the House the Gas Boom Built 4th grade · age 9

Was the Kokomo Board of Trade right to give factory owners like Monroe Seiberling free gas and free land to get them to build in Kokomo?

Under what conditions should a community give money, land, or other help to outsiders in hopes of benefiting the whole town?

The Judgment Lab asks: What do we think about that? When we work on the Judgment Lab, our ultimate goal is to articulate our own principles and values in a thoughtful and respectful way.

As you read, in 1886 Kokomo, Indiana, was a small farming town of about 4,000 people. Then local businessmen chipped in money to drill for natural gas, and they found it. After the gas was discovered, Kokomo offered free natural gas and free land to factory owners to get them to build there. A businessman named Monroe Seiberling took advantage of these offers. He and his partners built The Diamond Plate Glass Company, which became the largest plate glass factory in the country.

Seiberling's factory was just the beginning. More and more factories were built in Kokomo, and new neighborhoods and shops grew up around them. In just four years, the town doubled from about 4,000 people to more than 8,000. Other towns in the gas belt did the same thing: they offered free gas and free land to attract factories.

The Judgment Lab asks under what conditions a community should give money, land, or other help to outsiders in hopes of benefiting the whole town. When we say "outsiders," we mean people who do not already live in the community but might move there or build something there if the deal is good enough. Monroe Seiberling, for example, was an outsider because he did not live in Kokomo. He came from somewhere else and built his factory only after the town offered him free gas and free land.

So, was the Kokomo Board of Trade right to give away free gas and free land to factory owners like Monroe Seiberling, or was that too big a price to pay?

Follow the steps below to complete this Judgment Lab. By the end of the lab, you will have decided whether you think Kokomo was right to give factory owners like Monroe Seiberling free gas and free land to get them to build in town. You will also articulate and test your principles about under what conditions a community should give money, land, or other help to outsiders in hopes of benefiting the whole town.

Step one

Generating claims

Was the Kokomo Board of Trade right to give factory owners like Monroe Seiberling free gas and free land to get them to build in Kokomo?

Yes

No

Step two

Articulating principles and values

Under what conditions should a community give money, land, or other help to outsiders in hopes of benefiting the whole town?

Always, never, or sometimes?

Principles

I think that a community should give money, land, or other help to outsiders in hopes of benefiting the whole town when...

Values and beliefs

I think that because I believe that...

Step three

Testing principles on a new case

Pullman's Company Town

In 1880, a rich railroad car maker named George Pullman bought several thousand acres of land just south of Chicago, Illinois. Instead of moving into a town that already existed, he built a brand-new town from scratch and named it Pullman, after himself. He built the factory where workers made fancy railroad sleeping cars, and he also built the houses, the stores, the church, the library, and even the park.

At first, many people thought Pullman was a wonderful place to live. The streets were clean, the houses had indoor water and gas, and visitors came from far away to see it. But there was a catch. George Pullman owned everything. Workers could not buy their houses — they could only rent them from him. They could not vote for a mayor or a town council of their own, because the town was really just his property. If a worker complained too much, he could lose both his job and his home.

In 1893, hard times hit the country, and Pullman cut his workers' pay. But he did not lower the rent they paid him for their houses. In 1894, the angry workers went on strike, and the strike spread to railroads all across the country until federal troops were sent in to stop it. A few years later, in 1898, the Illinois Supreme Court ruled that the Pullman company had to sell off the town, because a company was not supposed to own a whole town where people lived.

Apply your principle to the new case

According to your general principle, was the town of Pullman a good deal for the working people who moved there? Why or why not?

From Monroe Seiberling and the House the Gas Boom Built, a 4th grade history lesson on Pallas.

Free with your school email

Every file — the reading and notes PDFs, work pages, primary-source labs, and the teacher edition (slides, lesson plan, exemplars) — is free. Tell us your school or organization email and we’ll send the file straight to your inbox.

Personal addresses (gmail, yahoo…) won’t work — we build for classrooms. We will email you about new units from Pallas. No spam; unsubscribe any time.