Larry Bird 4th grade · age 9

The older, bigger boys on the grass court often left Larry out of their pickup games because he was younger and smaller. Should they have let him play?

Under what conditions do we owe help or a fair chance to someone who is smaller, newer, or weaker than we are?

The Judgment Lab asks: What do we think about that? When we work on the Judgment Lab, our ultimate goal is to articulate our own principles and values in a thoughtful and respectful way.

As you read, when Larry Bird was a young boy in the early 1970s, he badly wanted to play basketball with the older kids near the Lost River in Indiana. The kids played on a grass court with a wooden backboard nailed to a telephone pole. But the older, bigger boys left Larry out of their pickup games because he was younger and smaller. Being shut out made Larry angry and hungry to compete.

As you know, Larry went on to become one of the best basketball players ever. He led the Boston Celtics to three championships, was named an All-Star twelve times, and later won awards as a coach and a team builder. The Judgment Lab asks you to think back to those early days on the grass court: should the older boys have let him play?

The Judgment Lab asks under what conditions we owe someone a "fair chance." A fair chance means letting a person try, even if they might not be as good or as experienced as everyone else. Giving someone a fair chance doesn't mean you have to change all the rules — it just means you don't shut them out before they even get a turn.

Were the older, bigger boys right to leave Larry out of their pickup games just because he was younger and smaller?

Follow the steps below to complete this Judgment Lab. By the end of the lab, you will have decided whether you think the older boys should have let Larry play. You will also articulate and test your principles about under what conditions we owe help or a fair chance to someone who is smaller, newer, or weaker than we are.

Step one

Generating claims

The older, bigger boys on the grass court often left Larry out of their pickup games because he was younger and smaller. Should they have let him play?

Yes

No

Step two

Articulating principles and values

Under what conditions do we owe help or a fair chance to someone who is smaller, newer, or weaker than we are?

Always, never, or sometimes?

Principles

I think that we owe help or a fair chance to someone who is smaller, newer, or weaker than we are when...

Values and beliefs

I think that because I believe that...

Step three

Testing principles on a new case

Title IX and School Sports

Before 1972, most American schools spent almost all of their sports money on boys. Boys had basketball teams, baseball teams, uniforms, coaches, and gyms to practice in. Girls who wanted to play often had no team at all, or they had to play with old equipment at bad practice times. Many adults back then said girls were smaller and weaker, so sports were not really for them.

In 1972, Congress passed a law called Title IX. It said that schools that got money from the government could not shut people out of school programs just because they were boys or girls. That meant schools had to start giving girls real teams, real coaches, and a real chance to play.

Some people complained. They said the boys' teams had been there first and had earned the gym time, and that adding girls' teams would take money away. But schools followed the law anyway. In 1972, about 1 girl in 27 played a high school sport. Today, about 2 out of every 5 girls do. Players like Mia Hamm and Sheryl Swoopes grew up in that world and became stars, and millions of girls who never became stars still got to be part of a team.

Apply your principle to the new case

According to your general principle, should schools have been required to give girls their own teams and equal practice time? Why or why not?

From Larry Bird, a 4th grade history lesson on Pallas.

Free with your school email

Every file — the reading and notes PDFs, work pages, primary-source labs, and the teacher edition (slides, lesson plan, exemplars) — is free. Tell us your school or organization email and we’ll send the file straight to your inbox.

Personal addresses (gmail, yahoo…) won’t work — we build for classrooms. We will email you about new units from Pallas. No spam; unsubscribe any time.