Axl Rose Leaves Lafayette for Rock Stardom 7th grade · age 12

Should the people of Lafayette, Indiana, have claimed Axl Rose as their hometown star and celebrated him the way they celebrated other Indiana musicians?

Under what conditions does a community owe support and recognition to one of its own members who has broken its rules?

The Judgment Lab asks: What do we think about that? When we work on the Judgment Lab, our ultimate goal is to articulate our own principles and values in a thoughtful and respectful way.

As you know from the reading, William Bailey grew up in Lafayette, Indiana, a city with deep roots in church life and strict moral expectations. As a young kid, he fit right in — he sang in the church choir, competed in Bible-knowledge contests, and earned good grades. But by the time he turned sixteen, everything changed. He clashed with teachers, got kicked out of school, and started getting arrested for things like public intoxication and battery. The police even threatened to label him a career criminal. Facing that threat, he left Lafayette in 1982 and headed to Los Angeles to try to make it as a rock musician. He took a new name: Axl Rose.

In L.A., Rose reconnected with an old Lafayette friend, Izzy Stradlin, and together they helped form Guns N' Roses. The band's fearless attitude eventually caught the attention of a major record label, and their 1987 debut album, Appetite for Destruction, became the biggest-selling debut in American rock history. By 1991, Guns N' Roses was one of the biggest rock bands on the planet.

Even with all that success, something bothered Rose. He wanted Indiana to celebrate him the way it celebrated other famous musicians, but no one ever called him a hoosier rocker. He told a rock-history professor from Indiana University exactly how much that silence stung. The Judgment Lab asks whether Lafayette should have claimed Rose as their hometown star, even though he had broken the community's rules on his way out.

The Judgment Lab asks under what conditions a community owes "support and recognition" to one of its own members. Support means backing someone up — cheering for them, talking proudly about them, or helping them succeed. Recognition means publicly acknowledging what someone has accomplished, the way a town might name a street after a famous resident or include them in a local hall of fame. The general question asks whether a community should still offer that support and recognition when the person has broken the community's rules — as Axl Rose did when he got in trouble with the law and clashed with authority figures in Lafayette.

Did the people of Lafayette, Indiana, make the right call by not celebrating Axl Rose the way they celebrated other Indiana musicians — or should they have claimed him as their hometown star despite all the rules he broke on his way out?

Follow the steps below to complete this Judgment Lab. By the end of the lab, you will have decided whether you think Lafayette should have claimed Axl Rose as their hometown star and celebrated him the way they celebrated other Indiana musicians. You will also articulate and test your principles about under what conditions a community owes support and recognition to one of its own members who has broken its rules.

Step one

Generating claims

Should the people of Lafayette, Indiana, have claimed Axl Rose as their hometown star and celebrated him the way they celebrated other Indiana musicians?

Yes

No

Step two

Articulating principles and values

Under what conditions does a community owe support and recognition to one of its own members who has broken its rules?

Always, never, or sometimes?

Principles

I think that a community owes support and recognition to one of its own members who has broken its rules when...

Values and beliefs

I think that because I believe that...

Step three

Testing principles on a new case

Jim Thorpe's Olympic Medals

Jim Thorpe was born in 1887 in Indian Territory, in what is now Oklahoma, and was a member of the Sac and Fox Nation. He went to the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Pennsylvania, where he became one of the greatest athletes anyone had ever seen. At the 1912 Olympic Games in Stockholm, Sweden, he won gold medals in both the pentathlon and the decathlon — two of the hardest events in the whole Games. When he came home, New York City threw him a ticker-tape parade, and newspapers across the country called him the best athlete in the world.

Then, in 1913, a reporter discovered that two summers earlier Thorpe had played minor-league baseball in North Carolina and been paid a few dollars a week. Olympic rules at that time said athletes had to be amateurs, meaning they could never have been paid to play any sport. Plenty of college athletes did the same thing under fake names, but Thorpe had used his real one. The American Athletic Union stripped him of his titles, and the International Olympic Committee took back both gold medals and erased his name from the record books.

Thorpe went on to play professional football and baseball, and he was one of the first presidents of the organization that became the NFL. But he never got his medals back in his lifetime; he died in 1953. His family, his tribe, and supporters around the country kept pushing. In 1983 the Olympic committee gave replacement medals to his children, and in July 2022 — 110 years after the Stockholm Games — the committee finally restored Jim Thorpe as the sole champion of both events.

Apply your principle to the new case

According to your general principle, should the Olympic committee and the American sports community have restored Jim Thorpe's medals and celebrated him as a champion, even though he had broken the amateur rule? Why or why not?

From Axl Rose Leaves Lafayette for Rock Stardom, a 7th grade history lesson on Pallas.

Free with your school email

Every file — the reading and notes PDFs, work pages, primary-source labs, and the teacher edition (slides, lesson plan, exemplars) — is free. Tell us your school or organization email and we’ll send the file straight to your inbox.

Personal addresses (gmail, yahoo…) won’t work — we build for classrooms. We will email you about new units from Pallas. No spam; unsubscribe any time.